Education, gender, practical knowledge and migrant workers reveal the gap between Keralam’s progressive ideals and the realities of everyday life.
NV Paulose, Chairman, Global TV +91 98441 82044
A leaking tap, a loose cooker handle, a broken switch, a form that needs filling out, or a journey that could have been undertaken on foot. These may seem like insignificant details of everyday life. Yet, they tell us something important about how we are educated, how we organise our lives, what we value as knowledge, and the inequalities we continue to reproduce.
In a conversation between Dr. Praveena Kodoth and Dr. Jacob Mathew, ordinary domestic experiences become the starting point for a larger reflection on education, gender, labour and citizenship in Kerala. The conversation moves beyond the familiar language of degrees, professional titles and social development to ask a more uncomfortable question: Are we educating people to live independently and responsibly, or merely preparing them to acquire qualifications and credentials? It is a question that deserves attention in a society that takes considerable pride in its educational achievements and progressive social indicators.
The educated, and the things we still cannot do
We have built a culture in which educational qualifications are often treated as the ultimate measure of competence. Degrees, professional titles and institutional affiliations command respect. Yet, the ability to navigate the practical demands of everyday life is rarely considered equally important.
A person may possess advanced academic qualifications and still hesitate to repair a household fixture, operate a tool, manage a routine administrative task or undertake something that requires hands on familiarity. This is not necessarily a failure of intelligence or ability. It may simply reflect the opportunities, or the lack of opportunities, to acquire such skills. The problem is that we have gradually separated education from doing.
Much of what makes us capable in daily life is learnt through observation, repetition, experimentation and occasionally failure. We learn by watching someone repair something, by trying it ourselves, by making mistakes and by discovering that the problem was not as complicated as we imagined. These experiences build confidence and a sense of agency that cannot always be acquired through textbooks.
When education privileges theoretical knowledge while overlooking practical competence, it creates a peculiar kind of dependence. We become qualified to occupy professional spaces but may remain uncomfortable engaging with the ordinary material world around us. Perhaps education needs to be understood not simply as the acquisition of knowledge, but as the development of the capacity to act.
The invisible curriculum of gender
This gap between knowledge and practice is also deeply gendered. Dr. Jacob Mathew’s reflections on domestic responsibilities and the experiences of highly educated couples illustrate how formal education does not necessarily dismantle the expectations inherited through upbringing. Women and men may enter adulthood with similar qualifications, yet their familiarity with domestic work, technical tasks, paperwork, household management and care responsibilities can differ considerably. These differences are not simply personal preferences. They are shaped over years, beginning in childhood.
Girls are often introduced to cooking, cleaning, caring for younger siblings and organising household routines, while boys may be encouraged to engage with tools, repairs, mobility and activities outside the home. These expectations are not always imposed explicitly. They are communicated through everyday routines, what children are asked to do, what they are discouraged from doing, and what adults consider appropriate.
Over time, these repeated experiences become competence. What one child is encouraged to practise becomes second nature; what another child is never expected to attempt becomes intimidating. The irony is that domestic skills, particularly those traditionally associated with women, are often dismissed as instinctive. Cooking, sewing, cleaning, caregiving and household management are treated as things women simply know how to do. Their complexity is overlooked precisely because they are performed so routinely.
Cooking, for instance, involves planning, timing, resource management, sensory judgment, coordination and adaptation. Sewing involves precision, spatial understanding and the ability to work with materials. Care work requires emotional intelligence, patience, anticipation and an enormous amount of invisible decision making. These are skills. They are learned skills. And they deserve recognition as such. The absence of certificates does not make labour less skilled. Nor does the fact that it is performed within the home make it less valuable.
The politics of the hand
One of the most significant concerns emerging from the conversation is the decline of practical engagement, the ability to use one’s hands to make, repair, maintain and create. The phrase handedness, in this context, points to a broader relationship between the body, intelligence and the material world. Our hands are not merely instruments of labour. They are ways through which we learn, understand and engage with our surroundings.
A child who stitches, builds, repairs, plants, cooks or works with materials develops forms of intelligence that are difficult to cultivate through passive learning alone. Practical engagement teaches patience, precision, problem solving and an appreciation of how things work.
Yet these activities increasingly occupy a diminished place in our educational imagination. Manual work is frequently associated with lower social status, while academic achievement is seen as the route to upward mobility. Parents understandably aspire to careers that promise security and prestige. But somewhere along the way, the ability to work with one’s hands has come to be seen as something to escape rather than something to cultivate. This is a particularly troubling contradiction in a society that needs technicians, artisans, skilled workers, designers, repair professionals and people capable of translating ideas into tangible outcomes.
There is no reason why academic excellence and practical competence should be mutually exclusive. A school that introduces sewing, carpentry, gardening, electrical basics, cooking, repair and other practical activities is not lowering its academic standards. It is expanding the meaning of education. The ability to repair a leaking tap or reattach a broken handle may not appear on a résumé. But it represents something important: the confidence to engage with a problem rather than immediately surrender to it.
Progress that depends on private arrangements
Kerala has made significant strides in women’s education. Women have entered universities, professions and public institutions in substantial numbers. In fields such as medicine, their presence is especially visible. But educational access alone does not guarantee equality in the experience of work or in the distribution of responsibilities at home.
Women may acquire qualifications, secure employment and enter demanding professions, yet their ability to pursue career opportunities may still depend on how household responsibilities are negotiated. A supportive spouse, accommodating family members or access to paid domestic assistance can make the difference between pursuing a professional opportunity and declining it.
This is where individual success can obscure structural inequality. When a woman succeeds because her household responsibilities are redistributed fairly, that is an important achievement. But when such redistribution depends largely on individual negotiation rather than social arrangements that make it routine, equality remains uneven and fragile.
The question, therefore, is not whether women are capable of succeeding. They have demonstrated that repeatedly. The question is whether institutions, households and society are organised in ways that allow them to succeed without carrying a disproportionate burden of unpaid work. A society cannot claim gender equality simply because women have entered its classrooms and workplaces. It must also examine who cooks, who cleans, who cares, who remembers, who organises and who is expected to make professional ambitions fit around domestic responsibilities.
When a citizen becomes a guest
The conversation takes an even more compelling turn when it moves from the household to the wider community and considers Kerala’s migrant workers. The term Athithi Thozhilali, or guest worker, was introduced into public discourse as a more respectful alternative to the derogatory labels often used for migrant labourers. The intention was welcome: to recognise their contribution and replace language that demeaned them.
But language also carries assumptions about belonging. A guest is someone welcomed temporarily into another person’s space. Hospitality is offered, but the guest does not necessarily possess the same rights, security or permanence as the host. The relationship is defined by the host’s generosity.
Migrant workers in Kerala, however, are not merely guests in a social or economic sense. They are fellow citizens. They work, pay for goods and services, build homes and infrastructure, participate in the local economy and contribute to the everyday functioning of the state. Their constitutional rights do not depend on the hospitality of the people among whom they live.
This distinction matters. Research on migrant workers’ experiences in Kerala during the COVID 19 lockdown found that the shift to the term guest workers was viewed differently by different people. Some felt it conveyed greater dignity and acceptance. Others questioned whether the change in language translated into any meaningful improvement in their lives. Workers expressed concerns about wages, working conditions and material support, issues that cannot be resolved through terminology alone.
The limits of benevolent language become apparent when workers continue to face precarious housing, insecure employment, barriers to welfare, social suspicion or exclusion. Calling someone a guest may express kindness. But kindness is not a substitute for rights. A truly inclusive society does not merely welcome people when it is convenient or when their labour is needed. It recognises their dignity irrespective of whether they are perceived as outsiders. The test of inclusion is not the vocabulary we use, but the institutions, protections and everyday attitudes that accompany it.
The fragile boundaries of us
There is also something revealing about the way collective identity works in Keralam. In moments of crisis, celebration or shared pride, internal divisions can temporarily recede. We become conscious of a common identity, of belonging to a place and participating in a shared history. Yet this sense of unity can coexist with the exclusion of those who are seen as different, different in language, region, appearance or cultural familiarity.
The boundaries of belonging are often invisible until someone crosses them. The migrant worker who builds our houses, cleans our streets, works in our restaurants, supports our businesses and helps sustain our urban and rural economies may be indispensable to our everyday lives, yet remain socially distant from the idea of who we are.
This contradiction should make us pause. Citizenship cannot be reduced to familiarity. Belonging cannot be measured by accent, place of birth or the length of time someone has lived among us. If we celebrate Keralam as a society committed to social justice, we must extend that commitment beyond those who already fit comfortably within our imagined community.
Rethinking what it means to be educated
The conversation between Dr. Praveena Kodoth and Dr. Jacob Mathew is valuable precisely because it begins with ordinary life rather than abstract theory. It reminds us that social inequalities are reproduced through small, familiar practices: who is taught to repair, who is expected to care, which skills are respected, whose labour is invisible and who is treated as belonging. These are not peripheral concerns. They are central to how a society functions.
Perhaps we need to rethink the meaning of education and progress. Education should give us the ability to think critically, but also to act competently. It should encourage ambition without teaching contempt for manual labour. It should prepare us for professional life without making us dependent on others for the simplest practical tasks. It should challenge inherited gender roles rather than merely equip women to navigate them. And it should cultivate an understanding of citizenship that is grounded in equality, not conditional hospitality.
A truly educated society would recognise the intelligence involved in repairing, making, caring, organising and sustaining. It would understand that equality begins at home but cannot end there. It would recognise migrant workers not as temporary guests to whom we extend kindness, but as people whose rights and dignity are non negotiable.
Progress is not simply the number of degrees we earn, the professions we enter or the indicators we celebrate. It is also reflected in whether we can fix what is broken, share the work that sustains us, value the skills that remain unseen, and recognise the people around us as equals. Perhaps the measure of a society’s education is not merely what its people know, but what they are capable of doing, and whom they are willing to recognise as belonging.
