Reflections by Dr. Praveena Kodoth and Dr. Jacob Mathew: Work, Dignity and Women’s Independence
NV Paulose, Chairman, Global TV +91 98441 82044
Women’s employment is often discussed in terms of financial independence, household income and economic empowerment. While these are important considerations, they do not fully explain why so many women wish to work, even when their families are financially secure. Work offers something beyond a salary. It provides social interaction, a sense of identity, self worth, independence and the opportunity to participate in a world beyond the confines of the home.
A conversation between Dr. Praveena Kodoth and Dr. Jacob Mathew brings these dimensions into focus through the experiences of employed and unemployed women in Kerala. Their discussion reveals that the desire to work is not necessarily driven by economic deprivation. It is also driven by the need to lead a meaningful life, maintain social connections and preserve one’s dignity.
Employment as Freedom, Identity and Social Belonging
For many women, employment is a gateway to the world outside the family. A workplace offers opportunities to meet people, develop friendships, exchange information, discover new possibilities and participate in a larger social environment. These experiences are difficult to quantify, yet they contribute significantly to personal wellbeing. Even women who are financially comfortable and have no compelling need to earn may be reluctant to give up their jobs. Work gives structure to their lives, keeps them intellectually engaged and allows them to retain an identity independent of their roles within the family. The question, therefore, is not merely whether a woman earns enough to sustain herself, but whether she is happy to give up the social and psychological space that employment provides.
The experiences of women who have been compelled to discontinue their careers reveal how deeply this desire for work can be felt. One woman interviewed had completed her education and undertaken social work, but her employment came to an end after marriage. She described how circumstances, pregnancies and family expectations repeatedly prevented her from returning to work. Although she had a family and five daughters, she remained unhappy about having lost the opportunity to work. Ironically, she wanted her daughters to become educated, employed and independent, even though she herself had been denied that freedom.
Another woman, a qualified nurse who had studied in Vijayawada and worked in Hyderabad, had to return home following pressure from her parents to marry. After marriage, caring for her children and elderly parents in law made it difficult for her to resume employment. Yet she continued to look for opportunities. She was willing to accept even modest remuneration because earning something of her own meant that she would not have to depend on others for every small personal expense.
These experiences demonstrate that employment is closely connected to dignity and autonomy. A woman may have a comfortable home and a family that provides for her needs, but the inability to earn, make independent decisions or participate in the world outside can leave her feeling unfulfilled. The distinction between being cared for and being independent is important. Financial security within a family does not automatically translate into personal freedom.
Entrepreneurship and the New Possibilities of Working from Home
When women are unable to access conventional employment, entrepreneurship has increasingly opened up alternative possibilities. The growing presence of home based food businesses, baking enterprises, catering services and small scale ventures in Kerala reflects how women are creating opportunities within the constraints of domestic life.
The availability of home cooked food, cakes, snacks and other products through local networks has become particularly visible. Social media platforms such as WhatsApp and Facebook have enabled women to market their products, establish customer networks and build businesses without necessarily having to invest in a physical shop or commercial space. This development is significant because it creates a pathway to economic participation for women who may otherwise remain outside the workforce. Women who have domestic responsibilities, limited mobility or difficulty returning to formal employment can use their existing skills to generate income and establish a degree of independence.
The emergence of such enterprises also challenges the assumption that meaningful work must necessarily take place within a conventional office or institution. Entrepreneurship allows women to transform skills developed at home into economic activity. Cooking, baking, food preparation and other forms of domestic expertise, which have traditionally remained undervalued, can become sources of income, professional identity and social recognition.
However, home based entrepreneurship should not be romanticised as a substitute for accessible, decent and secure employment. Women may still face the challenges of managing production, marketing, financial risk and domestic responsibilities simultaneously. The opportunity to work from home is valuable, but it should expand women’s choices rather than become another expectation that they must earn while continuing to shoulder the entire burden of household work. The larger significance lies in the fact that women are finding ways to remain active, productive and connected to society, even when conventional employment is inaccessible.
The Dignity of Labour, Skill and Recognition
The discussion also raises important questions about the dignity of those who perform domestic work, community work and care work. Domestic workers, caregivers, sanitation workers and community health workers sustain households and communities, yet their labour often receives inadequate recognition, training and remuneration.
The Haritha Karma Sena workers, who undertake waste collection and environmental management activities, illustrate this contradiction. Their work is essential to public health and environmental sustainability, but the conditions under which they work, the remuneration they receive and the social recognition accorded to them remain concerns. Many derive a sense of belonging and dignity from being associated with a public programme and serving their community, but this cannot justify inadequate compensation or the absence of fair working conditions.
The same contradiction is visible in the experience of ASHA workers. Their work extends into maternal and child health, public health awareness, community mobilisation and support for families, including migrant communities. In a state with low fertility and significant public health achievements, their role is particularly consequential. They are often required to negotiate difficult social situations, communicate across linguistic barriers and carry responsibilities that demand considerable knowledge, patience and commitment. Yet the value of their work is not always reflected in their remuneration or the institutional respect they receive.
Care work, whether performed by ASHA workers, domestic workers, caregivers or women within their own households, is frequently treated as an extension of women’s natural responsibilities rather than as skilled labour. This brings us back to the question of education and practical skills raised in the earlier part of the conversation. Domestic workers and caregivers should not be expected to navigate increasingly complex household technologies without adequate training. Modern kitchens, induction cooktops, chimneys, washing machines, microwaves and other appliances require familiarity and confidence. Training programmes could equip domestic workers with these skills, improve their employability, enhance the quality of services they provide and enable them to negotiate better wages.
Such training should not be limited to basic household routines. It could include food preparation, appliance operation, hygiene, safety, caregiving, nutrition, communication and the responsible use of technology. Domestic work could be recognised as a skilled occupation with opportunities for professional development.
The dignity of labour is not secured merely by expressing appreciation for workers. It requires fair pay, appropriate training, safe working conditions, respect and the recognition that those who perform essential work are entitled to dignity and opportunity. Women’s employment must be understood as more than a means of earning income. It is a means of participating in society, building relationships, exercising agency and shaping one’s own life. Whether a woman works in a college, hospital, office, home based enterprise or as a community worker, her work carries value beyond its economic contribution.
A society that values women’s freedom must create conditions in which they can work because they want to, continue working when they choose, return to employment after interruptions and acquire skills throughout their lives. Equally, it must ensure that the women who sustain households and communities through domestic and care work are not left invisible. The measure of progress is not simply how many women enter employment, but whether they are able to work with dignity, retain their independence and participate meaningfully in society.
